[ home ] [ pony / townhall / rp / canterlot / rules ] [ arch ]

/townhall/ - Townhall

A place for civilized animals
Name
Email
Subject
Comment
File
Flags  
Embed
Password (For file deletion.)

[Return][Go to bottom]

 No.15837[Last 50 Posts]

File: 1750189677081.jpg (311.36 KB, 1895x1500, 379:300, Duluth-lynching-postcard.jpg) ImgOps Exif Google

How come calling out racist activity gets called "anti-white racism" here?

Why is calling out racists, bigots and fascists a no-no?

Why do cowards always fail to face the violence of the past?

 No.15838

>>15837
Your distant ancestor was a murderer.  Therefore you deserve the death penalty as atonement for the violence of the past.  Or are you a coward?

 No.15839

File: 1750190578213.jpg (205.07 KB, 652x902, 326:451, Tumblr_l_41090249975520.jpg) ImgOps Exif Google

Americans have an entitled narcissism problem regardless of any identity. It's emotionally far easier,  on the fragile ego of people who cannot build a sense of self worth independent of what value they perceive in their innate unchangeable identities, to believe that their ancestors are morally perfect. Honestly it boggles me how many white people cannot just recognize they are already morally superior to their own ancestors. Plus it's easier to just play the easier to play the entitled victim when one's worldview is challenged by facts than to go through the scary and potentially humiliating process of re-examining one's worldview.

It's honestly amazing how ridiculously fragile the "fuck your feelings" crowd are sometimes

 No.15840

File: 1750190803737.jpg (262.92 KB, 515x597, 515:597, Tumblr_l_451805813069783.jpg) ImgOps Exif Google

>>15838
>>15838
>Therefore you deserve the death penalty as atonement for the violence of the past.

That's the most ridiculous strawman ever.

Challenging a person's culturally conservative worldview isn't the same as calling for their death.

 No.15842

>>15840
He specifically cited the "violence of the past." He said that people who do not face it are cowards. We can extend this view to any wrong committed by anyone in the past, and the notion that anyone descended from said individuals, much less anyone who is superficially similar, must answer for those wrongs.

 No.15843

>>15840
Some white person somewhere did something wrong therefore all white people must atone for it oh by the way give money to my charity of choice too else you're a bigot. Hilarious.

 No.15844

File: 1750193223846.jpg (2.24 MB, 1200x1800, 2:3, Tumblr_l_452289526539182.jpg) ImgOps Exif Google

>>15842
>We can extend this view to any wrong committed by anyone in the past, and the notion that anyone descended from said individuals, much less anyone who is superficially similar, must answer for those wrongs.

That's not even close to a logically valid. Criticism of the sins of past people is implicitly an argument against blind hero ancestor worship dude. It's a reminder to remain humble, nothing about it implicitly demands anyone 'answer' for the sins of the past but to learn from it.

>>15843

Grow the fuck up dude, no one is telling you to 'atone' for anything

 No.15845

>>15844
You clearly slept through Black Lives Matter and its aftermath.  At least some people got some nice mansions out of weaponized guilt by proxy.

 No.15846

Sometimes I really wonder whether certain people get the thrill out of being the most insufferable pieces of shit in the world.

Cause in the last few years it's gotten really competitive.

 No.15847

File: 1750195613610.jpg (1.74 MB, 1898x2913, 1898:2913, Tumblr_l_452242842546908.jpg) ImgOps Exif Google

>>15845

Of course I was paying attention, I just wasn't paying attention to only right-wing news sources regurgitating the same bullshit that they've been spewing since the days of Rush Limbaugh in the 90s. I recognize the same basic narratives and dishonest cherry picking of facts to reframe themselves as the totally innocent victim and suggesting we must identify with committers of hate crimes.

Sorry (not sorry), I have an individual identity, if another white person is a cop using disproportionate, even lethal force against a black suspect accused of passing a counterfit bill, in a world where white cops get away with that way too easily, I'm not going to interpret criticisms of that kind of corruption of the system as a criticism of every single white person, because I am not the one killing suspects over minor crimes. Why the fuck can't people like you accept that criticisms of the system are not criticisms of you for veing white? Why would you let yourself be manipulated into taking those criticisms as personal attacks.

I used to believe that shit 33 years ago when I heard that bullshit after the LA riots in 1992. I refuse to be cucked by that cowardly bullshit ever again.

 No.15848

The concept of white guilt is laughable. White people shouldn't feel bad about slavery because it happened over 100 years ago.

You know where people own slaves to this day? Africa.

 No.15850

File: 1750198079282.jpg (733.13 KB, 1619x2239, 1619:2239, Tumblr_l_452298675228449.jpg) ImgOps Exif Google

>>15848

Reframing humility as guilt is deeply dishonest.

 No.15853

>>15837
It's not, and nobody thinks it is.

If you're getting called out for racism, and yes "anti white racism" is just racism, it's probably because you keep being racist.

 No.15854

>>15837
>>15847
>Why the fuck can't people like you accept that criticisms of the system are not criticisms of you for veing white?
Because there is an ulterior motive.  Bringing this stuff up for the millionth time makes no difference vs the previous 999,999 times and will have the same exact non-outcome.  It's just yet another opportunity for people with nothing going on in their lives to selectively feign moral superiority over others.

 No.15855

>>15847
While I'm perfectly happy to see cops land in prison, get lynched, hung, shot, or whatever you fancy, acting like "lethal force" was used on Floyd is just absurd.
Man had a fentenal overdose. He literally requested to be pulled out of the car. The knee wasn't even on his neck.
Calling it "lethal force" is just idiotic.
And this is coming from someone frankly rather hardline on the ACAB type rhetoric.

Also: Black cops are just as bad as white cops, they get away with the same shit. You're just distracted from the issue because you're blinded by race.

 No.15856

>>15850
You shouldn't feel "humility" because of past crimes, either.
The son of a rapist bears no guilt for that action.
He should find no humility from it either.
He has committed no wrongdoing.
He has no responsibility for what came before.

 No.15857

>>15854
>Because there is an ulterior motive.  Bringing this stuff up for the millionth time makes no difference be the previous 999,999 times and will have the same exact non-outcome.
^^^^^ This 10000%

No police reform will ever occur when you guys accept blindly the narrative that these issues are created from racism.

Police are actively held above the law, to a different standard, regardless of what they do to white OR black people. It happens to EVERYONE. They can, and will, fuck you over, and there will be exactly 0 punishment. You will at best have to go through years of litigation to get some money, that comes from the TAXPAYERS not even the cops, while they continue on in their job.

This kind of crap just turns it into a political "right vs left" issue, that's a mile easier to combat.

 No.15858

>>15837
If you're a regular person, then you tend to think of bad things just being bad.

And so your cousin being a victim of racism is bad exactly the same as your other cousin coming down with pneumonia and yet other being the victim of a rabid dog attack (to refer over to another chat here).

If you're somebody with the brain-worms about either politics specifically or life in general, then you're going to have to twist yourself into knots about how over racism is fine if it benefits you (or doesn't hurt you) while it's bad if it hurts you.

And whether you're a freaky Proud Boy psychopath or a genuine communist or just some incoherent idiot, whatever you are, you're basically going to fail horribly and look to everybody else like a cringe Tiktok come to life.

Anybody screaming out about how some gang of white skinheads beating up a black grandmother to steal her purse isn't "racist" or like that militants of the New Black Panther Party marching with rifles going "whites have too many babies" isn't racist... like... what even do I need to say?

If you're a normal person and not a complete idiot, then you're just going to believe that bad things are inherently bad. And less bad things is good. The end.

If you're some kind of tribalist obsessive of whichever political side, or if you're just a moron, then you're going to have to sputter "well, actually, bad things are good if I say so" and be cringe as fuck forever.

 No.15859

Also, as somebody who literally had family that're police officers and literally myself used to work for a local police department myself (not as a cop), I've got to make this plea.

Please, Americans, stop being fucking morons who view your cops as superhero saints that say and do everything perfectly.

I feel literally like vomiting day after day when I see how badly you idiots blindly think that everything cops say, do, think, and whatever is correct.

The term "blind sheep" is an insult to sheep. Americans treat cops like horny, desperate men at strip clubs treat strippers. It's not just worship. It's slobbering worship.

Please stop that.

A white and pale as Casper the Ghost cop can beat a little teenage boy who's just as pale and white almost to death, basically because that police officer felt that his precious, precious feelings got hurt, and 0.00000001% of Americans or whatever the hell will find a problem with that. Well, I've got a problem with that. Stop. The. Fucking. Hero. Worship. Cops are regular human men. With regular human frailties.

If anything, I'd trust a fucking janitor cleaning a bunch of men's toilets to protect public safety better than a randomly chosen cop. The guy with the mop probably has better life experience. I'm dead fucking serious.

 No.15861

File: 1750201164423.jpg (205.07 KB, 652x902, 326:451, Tumblr_l_41090249975520.jpg) ImgOps Exif Google

>>15854

That's clearly a cope dude. It's an argument against a conservative worldview. An argument that restoring the past isn't preferable for the future. And calling out places where it's still a problem, like in the culture of American law enforcement, is part of the process of mitigating the problem. If you're not supporting racism in law enforcement, then it's not a criticism of you. The fact that things like this have been slow to change does not indicate that people who make such criticisms are doing so for the ulterior motive of 'feigning moral superiority'. And, candidly, it comes off to me as if one identifies with the cause of the problem, as if one identifies with those who are white supremacist.

>>15856

Do you even know what humility is? You seem to treat it as a synonym for guilt, which it absolutely is not.

Humility is being able to accept all shortcomings of oneself and one's identities, especially one's potential future shortcomings and being able to accept and learn from the mistakes of the past. Personally, I am really fucking sick of the fragility of my fellow white folk, especially my fellow southern white folk.

 No.15862

>>15861
When people here keep bringing up the same idiotic talking points over and over and shoving it in our faces as if we somehow condone the evil deeds of people who are not ourselves from the distant past, how do you propose we respond to that? Bad thing happened in the past, so fucking what?

 No.15863

>>15861
>Humility is being able to accept all shortcomings of oneself and one's identities,
That's precisely my point, and exactly as I was using it.

You bear absolutely zero responsibility for someone else's crime.
You have absolutely zero shortcomings that come from that past crime.

Feeling "humility" for someone else's actions is just dumb.
You didn't do it.
You aren't responsible.
They aren't your mistakes.

If anything, you ought be able to take pride in the fact that you haven't done such a thing, wouldn't do such a thing, and can categorically declare it to be evil.

>Personally, I am really fucking sick of the fragility of my fellow white folk,
"feel bad about past crimes or else ur fragile, whiteman!"
Yeah, I wonder why people accused you of racism...

 No.15864

>>15850
Being blamed and expect to 'fix' what your ancestors committed to isn't humility. That's passing blame.

I dont think humility means what you think it means

 No.15865

>>15859
Most people don't worship cops. They just want them to do their jobs and respect that it's a hard one. Without police we would end up like Detroit or Chicago where they just straight up dont respond

 No.15866

>>15865
Stopping cop worship and then treating cops to the criticism that they deserve doesn't mean abolishing the police.

Jesus Christ, dude.

Stop being retarded.

And, in reality, calling the cops in major cities in America is more likely to result in them making things worse for you as a crime victim. Not better.

Cops have no legal obligation to do anything for you as a crime victim. None. You can easily look this up.

 No.15867

https://www.findlaw.com/legalblogs/law-and-life/do-the-police-have-an-obligation-to-protect-you/

This needs to be screamed from the rooftops for everybody. And basically daily. Everybody in America needs to be reminded of this constantly.

Cops don't have a legal obligation to help you. Nor do they have a moral one. They don't. They just don't.

This is a matter of objective fact.

Cops. Aren't. Obligated. To
Help. You.

 No.15868

>>15865
Nah, I can tell you from personal experience, people do totally by large hoist cops up on a pedestal.
The reality is cops're more likely to lie, more likely to escalate an encounter, more likely to use violence where none is needed. And yet every time, folk'll excuse their actions, believe them when they obviously lie, and insist victims 'deserved' it either for 'resisting' (read, cop says they did) or for some other nebulous action somewhere else they 'probably' did.

 No.15869

FRIENDLY REMINDER:

In 2005's 'Castle Rock v. Gonzales', a woman sued the police for failing to protect her from her husband after he violated a restraining order in terms of having abducted and killed their three children. Justices said that the police couldn't be faulted there. Supreme Court of the U.S. said that.

"[T]he framers of the Fourteenth Amendment and the Civil Rights Act of 1871, 17 Stat. 13 (the original source of §1983), did not create a system by which police departments are generally held financially accountable for crimes that better policing might have prevented".

https://caselaw.findlaw.com/court/us-supreme-court/545/748.html#:~:text=Respondent%20alleges%20that%20petitioner%2C%20the,that%20her%20estranged%20husband%20was

Cops. Are. Not. Obligated. To. Help. You. Even. In. Terms. Of. Child. Murder.

 No.15871

>>15868
Every single word of this is as true as saying that 2 plus 2 is 4. Yes.

 No.15873

File: 1750204865174.jpeg (4.72 KB, 265x190, 53:38, images - 2025-06-17T19282….jpeg) ImgOps Google

>>15837

Гунз, нво

Russian fighter jets carpet bomb in the United States.

The Russians prove that the white race is a cheap trick. We should plant somewhere.


Buy my Angel dippers. We got that good good wet, 7 dollars a peace

I like sugar and i like tea....

 No.15874

Lackluster posted a video just a bit ago that rather perfectly demonstrates my point.

Police are all scum.
They lie as easily as breathing.
They will attack you without provocation.
They know they will be protected, not even just from legal reprecussions.
Their chiefs, sergeants, lieutennants, ect, will cover for them.
They won't lose their jobs. They won't go to jail. They won't even have to pay for the inevitable civil case.
You will.

This is why I say quite happily, every single cop is a piece of shit.
Not some.
Not most.
Every. Single. One.
Because they all back the blue.

 No.15879

>>15874
Way, way more people need to watch videos of American cops nakedly lying, cheating, stealing, and doing other wild shit.

 No.15880

File: 1750221475243.gif (466.16 KB, 863x1092, 863:1092, Tumblr_l_452251860299352.gif) ImgOps Google

>>15862

Because it's an argument against resurrecting that past, an argument that no one here seems to even engage with on a honest level.

>Feeling "humility" for someone else's actions is just dumb.
>You didn't do it.
>You aren't responsible.
>They aren't your mistakes.

Humility isn't taking responsibility for others mistakes, it's not even about taking responsibility, it's about rejecting arrogance. Having humility for your group identity means accepting that not everyone in your personal ingroup are going to be perfect either.

>If anything, you ought be able to take pride in the fact that you haven't done such a thing, wouldn't do such a thing, and can categorically declare it to be evil.

Agreed, but ... if you're confident in that than why would people here in this board be so stupidly sensitive about it to the point they would call even mentioning the past anti-white racism?

>"feel bad about past crimes or else ur fragile, whiteman!"
>Yeah, I wonder why people accused you of racism...

That's not at all what humility is and that's not what I am saying anyone needs to do,  nor anyone else who even simply mentions the past.

>>15864
>Being blamed and expect to 'fix' what your ancestors committed to isn't humility. That's passing blame.
>I dont think humility means what you think it means

If you think that being asked to be humble about being a white American means taking blame for racism in the past, then it's you who doesn't understand what humility means.

 No.15882

>>15880
> it's about rejecting arrogance.
By "accepting one's future shortcomings" because of the past crimes of someone totally disconnected from you beyond the color of their skin?
Why is refusing such an association in the first place "arrogance"?

>Having humility for your group identity means accepting that not everyone in your personal ingroup are going to be perfect either.
Because I am not a racist, I can accept that rather easily without needing to internalize some ancient crimes I have nothing to do with.

The color of someone's skill doesn't mean they're going to agree with me, relate with me, any of that. I don't need "humility" for a group identity in order to realize that.

>Agreed, but ... if you're confident in that than why would people here in this board be so stupidly sensitive about it to the point they would call even mentioning the past anti-white racism?
I don't believe that's what's occurring.
Rather, I think you yourself have made it pretty clear what people're actually pointing out;

When you complain about the "fragility of my fellow white folk", because they unlike you don't want to have the weight of someone else's past crimes upon them, I don't think it's unreasonable for one to point out the bigotry present in that statement.

> that's not what I am saying anyone needs to do,
Then what "should" be done with such information? Because feeling "humility" for it certainly seems to fall into that category, from what you yourself have described.
It's a "shortcoming" that stems from your identity. One that evidently brings "potential future shortcomings" as well, no less. All because of a race you happen to share, alone.  And if you don't "accept" that "mistake", well, you're just a fragile white guy.

Honestly, I just don't see how it's anything other than "feel bad about this for my political advantage".

 No.15889

>>15842
>>15843
It's amazing how much you people take what some random radical minority says sometimes and then act like it's a inescapable disease among the left and have to paint every random leftist you encounter the same way.
>>15858
>And whether you're a freaky Proud Boy psychopath or a genuine communist or just some incoherent idiot, whatever you are, you're basically going to fail horribly and look to everybody else like a cringe Tiktok come to life.
While I'm not a communist, I don't think one of these things is like the other. Communism is probably the most misunderstood ideology from those who identify as communists to those who oppose it to those who are neutral. Perhaps the idea isn't ideal for many people and that's fair, but acting like it's inherently bad just because of what a bunch of vanguardists did years ago who betrayed most ideals they claimed to uphold at every turn is incredibly reductive.

 No.15890

>>15889
Personally I'd say it's bad because every time it's been tried it has resulted in mass murders, genocides, and totalitarian regimes.

 No.15892

File: 1750225754300.jpg (177.51 KB, 750x1000, 3:4, 5556.jpg) ImgOps Exif Google

>>15890
First of no, not "every time". But sure maybe you could argue that when people feel passionate enough about what they see as a good thing that must happen or otherwise be maintained then they may get out of control. You could say "the road to hell is paved with good intentions" but then this also brings every good idea into question. See also what I said: "just because of what a bunch of vanguardists did years ago who betrayed most ideals they claimed to uphold at every turn". You can find awful things inherently like this within fascism, nazism, and similar ideologies and movements (like the proud boys) but I challenge you to show me where any of this is encouraged inherently with communism itself and not just what some guy later said who became associated with it. This isn't even counting movements that just blatantly hijacked it and turned it into their own thing like the khmer rouge.
>and totalitarian regimes.
And it is a stateless ideology. Isn't that funny?

 No.15893

>>15892
It's funny that the Native American Genocide here attributed to "capitalism" largely predates the concept of capitalism itself.  Capitalism is really just shorthand for "thing I don't like" and is a Boogeyman hiding in every shadow

 No.15894

>>15880
>"Why do so many people here support 'thing?'"
>"Nobody here supports 'thing.' What are you talking about?"
>"YOU'RE A RACIST FOR NOT ACKNOWLEDGING YOUR SUPPORT OF THING HOW DARE YOU!"
every town hall thread created by idiot leftists.

 No.15897

>>15893
If you think capitalism is a huge boogeyman just look at communism and how even to this day many people who aren't even so much as socialists are randomly labeled communists. Obama, effectively a centrist was somehow seen as a communist to a bunch of weirdos even. The red scare was never just in one time or place, it never truly ended. The point here doesn't change whether or not it's capitalism. Why are we attributing things inherently to something that said something has nothing to do with inherently? I wouldn't say capitalism or mercantilism or whatever is inherently these things either even. I don't LIKE capitalism and have separate criticisms of it's perceived tendencies admittedly and I would prefer to replace it with a "libertarian" or still democratic system that is socialist but I am not saying that it inherently does any of these things is either. The point is neither is communism.

 No.15898

>>15892
There are absolutely multiple points throughout Marx's writing explicitly advocating, encouraging, and otherwise pushing for violence.
But then, frankly, I don't think it's worth discussing, considering you buy in to the "It's totally capitalism's fault people starve to death" nonsense.

 No.15900

>>15897
People literally do the exact same thing with naziism.
It's pretty much par the course to accuse an adversary, when it comes to ideologues.
You know how many times I've been told I'm a nazi here, on townhall, despite being a pretty radical anti-state individualist?

Don't worry about what tribalists throw around. Even they don't believe it. It's just a partisan attack.

 No.15901

>>15897
Because idiots make a false dichotomy of capitalism and communism.

 No.15905

>>15898
>There are absolutely multiple points throughout Marx's writing explicitly advocating, encouraging, and otherwise pushing for violence.
Violence against who and in what situation? Did Marx say to genocide a bunch of people because of their ethnicity or race? To stifle the working class's say in soviets and effectively use coercive force to create a more and more authoritarian and eventually totalitarian state at the expense of many other communists and socialists and continued betraying their own ideals even beyond that like the bolsheviks did when they set the standard? Did Marx advocate killing random people because they opposed The Regime? I'm not saying it may not be shit regardless, but not all violence is the same kind. You could attribute a fair amount to what Marx said I suppose, but I would say the majority of it was not something he'd even tentatively approve of in totality especially for how much of it also came against the working class and betrayed them. We're also not even touching on other forms of communism like anarcho-communism, libertarian marxism, primitive communism before all of this, etc. And none of these things even if they came from Marx are inherent to communism in a similar way to how a lot of forms of marxism deviate from marx's teachings a lot but hold certain core principles. It's a shame too because I think there are plenty of criticisms to be had about communism even as an ideology aside from all of this, but it can never be talked about because the focus is always on this. If you want to attack communism, it'd probably even be more effective to go for what it inherently is.
>But then, frankly, I don't think it's worth discussing, considering you buy in to the "It's totally capitalism's fault people starve to death" nonsense.
Posting a image doesn't mean I inherently agree with all it's aspects. It's there for a reason even if it's not entirely lining up with what I think. But whoever put that there likely did so because people buy into the "people starve to death because of communism" when it's not that simple. It's never remotely that simple. It's a factor for sure but it's also a oversimplification as it is with capitalism.

 No.15907

>>15900
>>15905
But as an example the japanese communist party for a long time advocated peaceful means and was far from the worst. And they almost got somewhere with it too.

 No.15911

>>15892
>"fit on this shirt"
>It's just a meme.
>It's just an image.
Come on...

 No.15912

>>15911
In that it's in reaction to someone associating things inherently with something it is not inherently just like the image is doing. I thought I already made this clear.

 No.15913

>>15911
>>15912
If it's still not clear, the point is showing their argument more or less used against the opposite of what they are arguing against and hopefully it's clear how absurd both or at least one is. Surely you've done similar before.

 No.15914

File: 1750239183368.jpg (42.56 KB, 474x334, 237:167, autobahn.jpg) ImgOps Exif Google

>>15892
>You can find awful things inherently like this within fascism, nazism
hitler accomplished some good things communism is just inept

 No.15915

>>15914
>hitler accomplished some good things communism is just inept
Do I even need to explain why this is absurd on so many levels? I hope I don't but just in case the bar is below hell and we're going to entertain "see this ideology that is centered around hate, imperialism, racial superiority, and totalitarianism and much more is better than an ideology centered around uplifting the working class, ensuring everyone has enough to survive, statelessness, and classlessness because a highway exists!", you could point to the industrialization that came from "communist" countries. Not that I endorse the means through which that often happened.

 No.15916

>>15915
those commie countries collapsed without losing a major war lmao

 No.15917

>>15916
Gee I wonder what happened to the people's republic of china. Then again, I doubt you're sincere considering a random literal nazi just showed up out of nowhere.

 No.15918

>>15917
not a nazi bro just stating the obvious

 No.15919

>>15918
Righttttt. Well I guess I'll give you the benefit of the doubt since I'm not a "commie" saying all of this.

 No.15920

>>15919
sure thing commie

 No.15921

>>15866
I'm not worshipping cops by any definition other than your own. But, if that is worshipping cops then I'm not going to stop.

Stay mad

 No.15922

>>15880
I dont think white people or anyone for that matter deserve to show humbleness for a past they did not directly contribute to.

 No.16028

>>15922
i think everyone should show humbleness towards white people

 No.16030

File: 1750280645120.jpg (6.98 KB, 207x243, 23:27, Raised fist.jpg) ImgOps Exif Google

>Nazis
>Hitler
Bitch I'm the villain..
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TtlLItOKg3c
>They don't understand the things I say on Twitter
>ALL MY N'S NZ'S N HH!
>N HH!

 No.16031

File: 1750280751789.jpg (32.79 KB, 644x459, 644:459, 2b clown.jpg) ImgOps Exif Google

>>15914
The nazi party was against smoking and advocated for animal rights. They also were cool with slaughtering humans, but I won't deny they had some good things going on for you if you were German/A German ally.

 No.16032

>>16030
Nonny, I don't think it's a very good idea to be posting heil hitler videos right now.

 No.16033

"Be humble to everybody" to be honest seems like a hard moral principle to criticize.

It's basically like "Don't masturbate in public" or "Don't sneeze on people" or "Do brush your teeth every morning before going outside" or "Do use toilet paper".

Of course, this is different than restricting it to "only a certain race should be humble".

As an absolute moral standard, though? It works. "Be humble."

 No.16037

File: 1750311613964.jpeg (52.83 KB, 686x493, 686:493, Hi I'm Daisy.jpeg) ImgOps Google

>>16032
It's deeper than that. You gotta analyze the lyrics.

"N's see my twitter but they don't see how I be feeling..
So I became a N*zi, yeah, bitch I'm the villain..
They don't understand the things I say on twitter. All my N's* Nz*s, N* HH

N HH, N HH, All my N'S Nz'S, N HH
They don't understand the way I be feelin"

I fuck with that. I think it is relevant.

 No.16038

File: 1750312368314.png (369.72 KB, 838x472, 419:236, Squidward rain.png) ImgOps Google

It's not about Kayne being a nazi at all. It's about Kanye getting fed up with being told what to do, what to say, and how to feel. It's about being misconstrued and having words twisted in the eyes of the judgemental majority or minority for that matter.

It's about saying "Okay you're calling me a monster. You're calling me the villain. Then I'm going to to be the villain."

It's completely relevant to this thread as well as the national political environment here in America. It's pure, raw, unfiltered emotion in the most human way possible.

Anyway, if people like this:
>>15837
>>15840
Are telling you to feel bad about the past and that you have to show others humility and be humble over it, then they probably aren't worth listening to or caring if they call you a coward because you're not willing to perform some song-and-dance humiliation ritual every time black people are brought up, or native americans, or [insert topic or group of people you're supposed to feel guilty about].

Life your life. Be a good dude, and ignore the useless shaming. It's funny how living a great life tends to piss these types of people off.

 No.16039

>>16037
>>16038
>It's about saying "Okay you're calling me a monster. You're calling me the villain. Then I'm going to to be the villain."
So he's saying the classic "i'm a nazi now because i was called a nazi"? That doesn't make it any better and his past of saying very nazi adjacent things doesn't help either

 No.16040

>>16038
>>16039
>Anyway, if people like this:
>Are telling you to feel bad about the past and that you have to show others humility and be humble over it, then they probably aren't worth listening to or caring if they call you a coward because you're not willing to perform some song-and-dance humiliation ritual every time black people are brought up, or native americans, or [insert topic or group of people you're supposed to feel guilty about].
>Life your life. Be a good dude, and ignore the useless shaming. It's funny how living a great life tends to piss these types of people off.
There are some people expecting much more than humility and what op is actually saying. There are people who will harass and dox you or try to tear you down at every turn with any resource possible I do actually get it to some extent, sometimes the "mob" gets carried away. But "not listening to or caring about" what they have to say doesn't look like what Kanye is doing here, what Kanye is doing here is even by his own admission in the song (" I got so much anger in me got no way to take it out") expressing his anger at honestly what is largely the consequences of his actions and words and just proving the people who came against him right by saying he's become what they called him. If the things he said and did prior really weren't who he is deep down and he was being incredibly stupid this is not the way to handle it. it's the tempting way to handle it but the correct way to handle it is to prove them wrong instead of right. Now if that already wasn't the case before, he can't blame anyone but himself for people seeing him this way. And he clearly cares otherwise wouldn't be making this with anger like he said himself. And you posting this with this in mind isn't the best look either with all of this said. Again I understand the impulse even personally I've been accused of all kinds of stupid things with much stupider reasoning than there is with Kanye but again this is just proving them right.

 No.16041

File: 1750318626295.jpg (82.24 KB, 504x994, 36:71, Bast Body.jpg) ImgOps Exif Google

>>16039
>>16040

Becoming the monster people claim you to be isn't always right, but it can feel justified.

On the opposite note it does remind me when say, black people for example or any other race claims to be peaceful and all that but then turns to violence when someone calls them a racial slur. Like "Ah yes, they think I am a violent criminal so I am going to break the law and violently attack them. That'll show them how peaceful and reasonable we are."

Like I said, I know at the end of the day it typically isn't the most mature thing go and do and be like "If you see me as this, then that's what I'll be."

In this case people had been calling Kanye a nazi for a long time over his comments on Jewish people ect. Maybe he felt misunderstood. I never kept up with it closely, but I can understand the feelings of frustration and the esclation it causes between people.

I was just posting it because it seems revelant to not just the tone of interaction I'm getting from this thread (Not that people in here are 'embracing the monster' but rather saying 'dude shut up, we didn't fucking do anything'. People are sick of the virtue signaling.) but rather the way many places within the country have turned when it comes to racial relations.

That and the song is, well.. Funny. It's fucking hilarious.

 No.16042

>>16041
>Becoming the monster people claim you to be isn't always right, but it can feel justified.
It can feel right and justified, but in many cases at least it's not. Most of the time all it does is make an ass of one's self and set one's self on a further angry bitter spiral downward.
>On the opposite note it does remind me when say, black people for example or any other race claims to be peaceful and all that but then turns to violence when someone calls them a racial slur. Like "Ah yes, they think I am a violent criminal so I am going to break the law and violently attack them. That'll show them how peaceful and reasonable we are."
That's also not a good way of handling it most of the time but I understand that more than this after Kanye said Hitler had a lot of redeeming qualities and denied the holocaust, rambled about the "jewish media", and just on and on kept praising nazis and hitler in the same breath and much more. When even Alex Jones was trying to push back on what he was saying you know it's bad. And it wasn't even just that interview. Kanye had a lot to prove he wasn't and instead he chose to double down and prove he was. So I really can't see any value in the video other than a cautionary tale of what not to do after you say things like that and much more. Whether it's somewhat relevant or not I think it's not a good idea is all I'm saying.
>but I can understand the feelings of frustration and the esclation it causes between people.
The problem is he did a lot to earn that reputation and he just kept doubling down, like I can't sensibly feel much for this guy other than understanding what it's like to be frustrated at what people say because he made his bed and now he's lying in it.
>but rather the way many places within the country have turned when it comes to racial relations.
It's a mess but like I said above I think this song is only valuable as a cautionary tale of what not to do. Anyway, I was mostly just giving advice especially since I can't stop you from posting it anyway. It seems more and more like you're similar to my past self or in some ways sometimes similar to my present self than either of us would be entirely comfortable with.

 No.16043

File: 1750320799940.jpg (168.62 KB, 850x850, 1:1, Bugs Bunny to be continued….jpg) ImgOps Exif Google

>>16042

I think the problem is that Hitler and the Nazi party where in fact charismatic. That is evident to this day. And they did have some really good ideas that resonated with a lot of people. I mean Hitler was on Time Magazine of all places and was well respected by a lot of the world even during the war. It wasn't until after he lost that the defamation really, really began to settle in.

I really don't care much for the guy. He's just another historical figure at this point who has been dead for almost 100 years.

(Personally if we're gonna talk murderers, I prefer Vlad the Impaler. Man was a savage)

People just tend to forget to separate that and the fact that they murdered a shit load of people; not just jews.

At the end of the day, I'm not saying what Kanye is doing is a smart move, but I understand it. It's one fueled on emotion, and I think most human beings on the planet can relate to letting emotion rule at least one or two decisions in their lives.

I don't agree with the exact message, but I can relate to the raw unfiltered pride and pain driven delivery of its message. "Fuck this."

 No.16044

>>16043
I understand it in the sense that I understand the impulse in a more generalized sense. But that's all the more reason to be wary of it (especially given what the video contains in visuals and lyrics). It's really the same thing with the nazis themselves they were humans who got wrapped up in bad ideas and emotions and much more complicated things. Many were also self-admitted liars and using propaganda but something led them to where they were. Maybe some were like actual "psychopaths" or something but I don't believe most were born nazis or something similar. That is controversial with some but it seems to be true and it's important to recognize because yes, in theory that could have been you or me or anyone at some point and we have to be at least somewhat careful to make sure that isn't the case.

 No.16045

File: 1750321796724.jpg (122.43 KB, 900x654, 150:109, Back alley night drive.jpg) ImgOps Exif Google

>>16044
People are wild. I think we can both agree on that. Regardless, we're talking about it. That's the point of art and expression I suppose.

I don't think it's something people have to walk eggshells around. This isn't the Warp and dealing with chaos daemon or anything. If anything, I say if you want to see what being a nazi is about; go right the fuck ahead. It doesn't hurt my feelings. And it shouldn't. I've had friends that were racist as fuck; against my own race even, but at the end of the day (I keep saying that lol) we saw eye to eye as individuals. Funny enough, a lot of them changed with time. Guess I have a knack for killing people with kindness. It also helps I know how to talk shit back and turn things from straight malicious to entertaining for everyone.

If you think about it, race is pretty funny. All of our differences are funny. And I don't think that's necessarily a bad thing.
https://youtu.be/2A3ryjroZW8?si=1pTuM93qSv_Tyylp&t=119
I really miss the days when people could just see eye to eye and say "I fucking think you're a piece of shit" and group of friends could say the most RACIST shit to each other while laughing without making it political.

I miss the military on that last bit. Goddamn we would roast each other.

 No.16047

File: 1750324127615.gif (56.83 KB, 215x190, 43:38, Eye rolling in uncertain u….gif) ImgOps Google

>>16046
>I simply suggested it probably wasn't a good look for you to post it to others here

Nah, not myself. I meant it general. I've mentioned it before, I don't really care if people here don't like me. I mean, it would be nice if I were accepted, but I am used to being a black sheep and a misfit. I get it, but I'm not going to follow the crowd on an idea if I don't really want to.

I feel it is better to be hated for being honest rather than loved for telling a lie.

>Or simply not being so incredibly hostile or worse about incredibly stupid things that produce no demonstrable harm or offense.

Hehe, yeah. Especially when it comes to jokes. I really love making my friends laugh. It's like.. when they laugh genuinely it's so infectious. It makes me want to just cackle like a little gremlin or something

In person it's so much easier to feel someone's personal boundaries, which I do respect. It's all about tact. Coming at me sideways and getting super pissed off and hostile actually makes me want to double down in most cases. But simply saying politely, but firmly "Hey I don't like that. Please stop." And I can suddenly go to my default politeness.

Believe it or not, I actually really hate making people feel upset unless I feel I have been wronged or someone I care about has been wronged. It actually really upsets me when someone feels sad. Hell, even somebody I don't know. I've actually made quite a few friends here and there that way.

It's weird. When I see someone getting unfairly treated or wronged or harmed, it's like this thing in my head snaps and I want to protect. Is that weird?

 No.16048

>>16047
Don't worry about my post deletion just was getting tired and feeling strange and thinking strange.
>It's weird. When I see someone getting unfairly treated or wronged or harmed, it's like this thing in my head snaps and I want to protect. Is that weird?
I can feel the same, although I don't know much we feel it over the same things

 No.16049

File: 1750324798898.jpg (50.87 KB, 640x480, 4:3, Bulma head injury.jpg) ImgOps Exif Google

Anyway, threads like this make me feel a little blue. Because I see sooo many people who are normally pretty wonderful to one another; that I recognize by posting style drawing their blades and clawing at one another's throats over opinions.

Like they don't even try to understand the opposite opinion. And I get it: even if you do, it might offend you. For example: I am hispanic. If someone says some stupid shit about mexicans or whatever, I might not agree with the thought, but that doesn't mean I automatically think they are a piece of shit by that merit alone. I'll try to understand it, and even if we can't agree that doesn't mean we have to kill one another over it, or even fight. We can talk civil like and try to understand our positions. Even if that opinion is malicious in nature and disgusting to me.

Everyone has their limits of course, but I feel most things even racist, sexist, or otherwise stereotypical in nature come from places of fear, anger, and misunderstanding.

I'll even say this and I don't care how people judge. I do not like the black community what so ever as it stands. Yet I have met so many wonderful black people in my life that it's made me realize while people and groups as a whole might not jive with you, you can always keep your mind open and your heart willing to give love to those who prove you wrong.

I like to be proven wrong. I enjoy meeting people that I get along with. That's why I don't care when I hear people make generalizations about myself because they don't apply. I know it, and I have proven time and time again to people like that, that I'm actually incredibly friendly to be around if you let me love you. I'm not perfect, but I try.

Anyway, I'm a little buzzed. I'm probably not making sense and rambling.

 No.16050

>>16048
I might not agree with everything you say, but if I saw you getting attacked I might jump in and actually fight to protect you. Something along those lines. I mean, I've literally broken up fist fights in the street before

 No.16051

>>16039
It's not an uncommon choice folk make.
There's a reason most the time you want to get someone out of a cult or such, you befriend them first. You catch more flies with honey.
And beyond that, becoming the 'dragon' so to speak after being prodded just feels good.

 No.16052

>>16043
Vlad was a gigachad who did nothing wrong tbh.
Kind of wild how his name's twisted outside of that region, though. Associated with bloodthirsty vampires, rather than the defiant hero he's oft seen as in his homeland.

 No.16053

>>16052
He was crazy, and malicious. Never get that twisted. He was actually insane after his time with the Turks, but yes, he did through arguably necessary cruelty saved his home and people.

Man actually did dip his bread in blood and wine while he ate. Left muslim turks impaled alive at the outskirts on purpose so that they would speak in the same language as them to warn them.

There's a story about two muslim turks who were messengers who refused to remove their head garments.. So he told them "If you don't want them removed you'll wear them forever" and had their turbans nailed to their skulls, killing them in the process.

Also inspired this METAL AS FUCK song about his life.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_k2TbI0NTCo

 No.16054

File: 1750355114811.jpg (2.24 MB, 1200x1800, 2:3, Tumblr_l_452289526539182.jpg) ImgOps Exif Google

Man you people went way out of your way to twist meanings of words to turn 'humility' into 'groveling' and 'guilt'.

Humble is not a gesture or something you show. It's a state of being where one can accept the fallibility of one's judgment while maintaining one's self-esteem. And having humility for one's ingroup does not mean groveling over their sins or taking responsibility for them, it just means being able to accept that their judgement was just as fallible as anyone else's and that sharing an identity with them doesn't make one better than anyone else.

Talking about racism in the past to make the point that the past wasn't better than the present isn't meant to shame anyone here in the present. It's meant to argue against mythologizing it, modeling the present or future after it and an argument against building one's identity around it. That's literally all it is.

You people are really fucking fragile if you can't accept that and insteas see it all as personal attacks against you for being white.

>>16049

>Everyone has their limits of course, but I feel most things even racist, sexist, or otherwise stereotypical in nature come from places of fear, anger, and misunderstanding.

I personally understand that that's true ... and that's why I call it cowardice, cause that's what it is. I try to have empathy for that, but I also have empathy for people who would suffer from the actions of the fearful and angry with no self control, I'm not going to see that as absolving the bigot who does the wrong thing out of that fear, anger or misunderstanding. If you tell me to have empathy for the nazi beating up a gay guy for simply being gay because he's fearful or angry or doesn't understand, you'll just make me hate the nazi that much more and judge you for not applying the same to the gay guy getting beaten up. "Oh you don't understand he's a bigot cause he's scared and doesn't understand", yeaah fuck off, it doesn't absolve anything.

 No.16055

>>16054
>accept the fallibility of one's judgment
There is no fallability in one's judgement that arises from past sins committed by someone else who is not you.
I had nothing to do with any of that. I wasn't even alive at the time.

>one's ingroup
Honestly I think the biggest issue here with all of this is that you're looking at race through, to be frank, a racist's lens.
Most of us do not regard race as an "in group".
Most of us belive it to be little more than a physical characteristic of which one should not be judged for.
One that has little bearing on them, as an individual.

>You people are really fucking fragile
>"AGREE WITH ME OR UR A BABY!!!1!!!"
Yeah, no, fuck off.


[]
[Return] [Go to top]
[ home ] [ pony / townhall / rp / canterlot / rules ] [ arch ]