[ home ] [ pony / townhall / rp / canterlot / rules ] [ arch ]

/canterlot/ - Canterlot

Site related staff board
Name
Email
Subject
Comment
File
Flags  
Embed
Password (For file deletion.)

[Return][Go to bottom]

 No.4788

File: 1563333605224.jpg (69.79 KB, 550x490, 55:49, faces_adorableclock.jpg) ImgOps Exif Google

If the mod team is seriously considering banning all images that contain a Nazi swastika, I would like the Communist hammer-and-sickle to also be banned.

But my preference would be to keep the same rules as before: shitposting with swastikas is verboten, but legitimate uses (e.g., screenshots from  Wolf3D in an appropriate context) are allowed.

Previous related thread: http://ponyville.us/canterlot/res/1099.html#1130

Thread tag: site discussion

 No.4789

File: 1563333814468.jpg (426.56 KB, 600x600, 1:1, Patchouli (8).jpg) ImgOps Exif Google

I just want the old rule to be put back into effect. That's it.

It never should have been gone in the first place.

 No.4790

File: 1563334098898.jpg (240.52 KB, 500x500, 1:1, 1377322659076.jpg) ImgOps Exif Google

>>4789
As far as I'm concerned this was just an oversight and all I was trying to do was shine a light on it.

 No.4792

File: 1563345355614.png (201.85 KB, 507x454, 507:454, u mad twi.png) ImgOps Google

Alo ban Christian symbols while we're at it.

Or religion symbols in general.

They can be controversial.

 No.4794

File: 1563347216174.png (237.29 KB, 500x600, 5:6, be0cb93cb7ccf548f9937a79a9….png) ImgOps Google

>>4788
>no more hammer n sicle

Why. has that symbol suddenly caused an influx of heated whether red-commies-are-taking-over arguments on Ponyville lately?

But you are just trolling itt on /canterlot, tsk tsk

>>4790
it was there before n nothing was discussed about removing it on purpose.

 No.4795

File: 1563347921973.jpg (113.48 KB, 429x600, 143:200, 20904750.jpg) ImgOps Exif Google

>>4794
>it was there before n nothing was discussed about removing it on purpose.
Exactly.

All I've been saying is "put it back" but apparently that's been controversial.

 No.4796

File: 1563351158737.png (117.36 KB, 347x336, 347:336, 1562268844800.png) ImgOps Google

>>4795
I don't see any controversy here.

Im sure the mods will fix this too.  Theyre slow like molasses.

 No.4797

File: 1563353928976.jpg (108.95 KB, 800x600, 4:3, Patchouli (193).jpg) ImgOps Exif Google

>>4796
You don't see it because it's all been deleted at my request, lol

I made a thread about it and then the nazi and nazi apologist anon came into the thread being racist so i remade it and Thorax deleted it for me.

 No.4798

File: 1563363503784.jpg (147.37 KB, 816x1024, 51:64, elephant-snake-safari.jpg) ImgOps Exif Google

>>4789
>I just want the old rule to be put back into effect.
>>4794
>it was there before

There was never a rule that flat-out banned all Nazi swastikas.  There were these two rules:
>Rule 7. Do not post content of an aggressively, ironically, or trollishly poor quality, designed to derail discussions, or otherwise make the site unusable or intolerable to our regular community;
>Rule 8. Do not post threads or posts that are deliberate provocations to certain users, or deliberate provocations concerning the topics of Race, Religion, Nationality, Political Opinion, or Membership of a Particular Social Group;  

They covered the cases where people got banned for posting Nazi swastikas.  Inoffensive posts with images that incidentally contained a Nazi swastika, such as discussion about The Man in the High Castle, were posted and allowed.

 No.4799

File: 1563388691787.png (71.68 KB, 308x350, 22:25, Unikitty (1).png) ImgOps Google

>>4797
My intent was to be dismissive of any weight to the words of nameless posters because they have no weight.

Like the one below, who argues against while his argument is actually for a general ban having always been the rule here.

Good ol Thorax.  

Im sure your reported unintentional omission in the rules will be corrected, the empty words of a false argument notwithstanding.

>>4798
Was that too strong?  Don't take it personally im just prejudiced against anons.

 No.4800

File: 1563393507988.gif (248.37 KB, 232x250, 116:125, FDB24837-7BBB-48C0-86E3-00….gif) ImgOps Google

>>4789
Why do you care so much?

This is the fourth thread on /canterlot/ about this shit. How the hell actually cares about supposedly “hateful”  symbols. Not that anyone is actually posting that kind of ting here.

 No.4801

>>4800
>supposedly “hateful”  symbols
While I agree that the Nazi swastika is not inherently hateful, it is a symbol of a regime that is infamous for having committed truly awful acts.  Even if people posting it are doing so not out of hate but merely as edgy shitposting, posting a swastika (in manner that indicates support or approval of the Nazi regime) really has no place on this site.

And most people who identify as Nazis or neo-Nazis are in fact hateful people.  Back when you still subscribed to Nazi beliefs, you were a rare counterexample.

 No.4802

>>4800
Of course a bigoted Nazi like you would never understand why hateful symbols are a problem. I'm not even going to bother trying to talk to you about it because I know nothing I say will have any effect other than causing an unnecessary argument.

>>4798
You literally lack any ability to refrain from being a pedant, dont you.

 No.4803

Friendly reminder that discussion on /Canterlot/ is to remain civil.

 No.4804

File: 1563425751540.jpg (37.6 KB, 505x576, 505:576, Patchouli (24).jpg) ImgOps Exif Google

>>4803
Sorry if that came across as unnecessarily rude.

 No.4805

File: 1563441460458.png (195.23 KB, 530x490, 53:49, 54F1A898-AE67-4088-A1E4-F7….png) ImgOps Google

>>4801
>it is a symbol of a regime that is infamous for having committed truly awful acts.
You could say the same about virtually any other country.

>>4804
Don’t worry about it. People are fairly tolerate of me, given my views.

 No.4806

File: 1563443824750.jpg (663.77 KB, 800x900, 8:9, 66.jpg) ImgOps Exif Google

>>4805
>You could say the same about virtually any other country.
You're right, and people should point out that sort of thing every time things like that happen.

>Don’t worry about it. People are fairly tolerate of me, given my views.
I wasn't apologizing to you! (just kidding)

anyways, that's enough of this, I've already said everything relevant to the topic i can.

 No.4807

File: 1563453043235.jpg (150.02 KB, 624x616, 78:77, capybara-and-cat.jpg) ImgOps Exif Google

>>4805
>You could say the same about virtually any other country.
When people see the Nazi flag, the first things that usually comes to mind are the Holocaust and the Nazis starting a world war that decimated Europe.  The modern German flag doesn't have this type of a strong association.  It's not about the country, but about the Nazi regime specifically.  I suppose the Nazis arguably did some good things as well (e.g., animal rights) but these are overshadowed by all the horrible things that they did.

 No.4808

Wow.

 No.4809

File: 1563976389111.png (695.89 KB, 853x1024, 853:1024, 465104652.png) ImgOps Google

>>4807
Its kind of hard to see the good in someone when they just burn down a center killing 45 people in it but hey he found and nursed a box kittens abandon under a bridge right after the attack.
 

 No.4810

File: 1564015779375.jpg (31.42 KB, 564x630, 94:105, happy28.jpg) ImgOps Exif Google

>>4809
Yes, propogating pest species like kittens is pretty heinous.

How does burning down people mitigate the cat crimes?

 No.4812

We're not planning to ban usage of the Hammer & Sickle. Right now the only "No" is Nazi symbolism. You can often discuss the meaning of the symbols without images portraying them on site.

This is not an invitation to post other controversial images, just discuss heavy topics with careful consideration and things should be well.

Individuals that accidentally post these symbols or use them in well-intentioned contexts won't be met with immediately harsh discipline or any such thing.

Further conversation about this will be done with other moderators until we arrive at a final conclusion.

The thread is also being locked due to a rather obscene amount of shitposting.

[Peppermint]


[]
[Return] [Go to top]
[ home ] [ pony / townhall / rp / canterlot / rules ] [ arch ]